刑事再審程序研究.pdf

1、山東大學(xué)碩士學(xué)位論文刑事再審程序研究姓名：張艷申請(qǐng)學(xué)位級(jí)別：碩士專業(yè)：法律指導(dǎo)教師：丁杰20060329山東大學(xué)碩士學(xué)位論文AbstractThispaperiscomposedoffivepartsThefirsttwoparediscussabouttheconcept，characterandthefunctionofthe口iminalretrialpr6cedureAfkrcomparingthecriminalretrial

2、proceduresofthetwolegalfamiliestheauthoranalysesthedefectsofthetheoreticalbasisandsystemsofchinasAtlastputforwardstherefo。rmsuggestionsCriminalretrialprocedurewhichisareliefmeasureplaysanimportantpaninrealizingjudiciaryf

3、air、humanrightsprotectionanduaifyhglawenforcementModerncontinentallawcountriesgenerallyinherittheancientRomanprincipleof“NonBisinIdemandalsostipulatecompletecriminalretrialprocedureBasedonthedifferentknowledgeoftheaim，th

4、eretrialpl_o∞dl玳ofthecontinentalIawcountriesisclassifiedasFrenchmodelandGermanmodelTherationaloftheFrenchmodelcanbegeneralizedaslimitedpunitivepowerandstIpmmacyofhumanrightsprotectionandtheGerflJanmodel’canbegeneralizeda

5、slimitedsubstantivemathprincipleBasedonthebeliefofprocedurejusticeandthetraditionofhumanrightsprotectionaccordingtothe“ruleagainstdoublejeopardy“，AnglonAmeri∞nlawcounlzi鼯don’tstipulatetheretrialpIoc就h聆butstipulatereliefp

6、r餓；edm瞄benefitingtheaccusedforexampletheaccused鋤applyforHabeasCorpus、Certiorari、etc、inspecialc越；esUndertheguideofthetheoryoffaetualityandthateverywrongwillberightedtakingthesubstantivetruthprincipleofproceduraltheoryasth

7、eoreticalbasisChina’SretrialprocedurepursuesmaxiⅢulnsubstantivetruthandignoresthe刪udgedforceanddeterminingforceofeffectivejudgements、proceduraljustice、efficiencyandhumanrightspmtectiomThecriminalretrialsystemofChinahasma

8、nydefects，forexamplethecasualstartoftheretrialprocedure、theblendofchargeandtrial、theimbalanceoftheeffectofappealandprotest、theirrationalityofthestartingI殘LSOns、thedisadvantageofthegovemanceofthesamecourt、ereIthasmanydefe

9、ctsinitsbeliefsandsystemsThefundamentalwayoutforthecriminaladjudicatorysupervisionprocedureofChinaliesinrenewaloflitigationtheoriesandalterationoflitigationnotionDrawinglessonsfromtheforeigncoentriesandconsideringChina’S