英語bp辯論

1、1.THBTcooperationbetterthancompetitioninpromotingsocialadvancement.正：cooperationisbetterthancompetitionEconomicglobalizationDuringtheAPECsummitChinesepresidentXiJinpingAmericanpresidentBarackObamaannouncedthattheirtwonat

2、ionswouldwktoreducegreenhousegases.反：cooperationisnotbetterthancompetition.Withoutthecompetitionbetweenthe2.THWrequirealladvertisersofmedicineshealthproductstoprovidescientificevidenceftheirclaims.正：medicineshealthproduc

3、ts反：advertisersPMLODPMDLOMGMOGWOWDPM:(Openingremarks:usingthestepsasshowninPPT)Mr.speakerMembersoftheHousetheleaderofoppositiontodayhastoldusthatcooperationisnotbetterthancoopetitioninpromotingsocialadvancement.Butwethin

4、kthiswillnotwkwell.Weshould…IndertosupptourstancetodayIwillhaveoneextensiononeargument.FirstlyIwillprovethewkabilityofourplantheargumentcaresabout….ButbefethatIwillgivetworebuttals.(Substantiation)(I.Rebuttals)(repairing

5、ientatedrebuttal)1…..(refutationientatedrebuttal)2…..(Extensions)(Challengingtheburdenofproof)(Thinkingofnewarguments)(Conclusions)TosumuptodayIhavegiventworebuttals:AllthosemadeourgovernmentsidebelievethatDLO:Mr.Speaker

6、membersoftheHouseladiesgentlemen:Comment[S3]:Giveacommentofthisargumentasaconclusion:SothankyoumemberofoppositionwhatyousaidisexactlythesametoourmodelComment[S4]:Warrantismissing.加上Theyputmestressonthebenefitofmediacover

7、ageofcelebrities’ment[S5]:Warrantismissing:加上Fromtheabovecontrastitisquiteobviousthatmediacoverageofcelebrities’privacycan’tfulfillthedutyofsupervisioneffectivelyastheoppositionbenchwishesbutonthecontraryitbringsaboutmeh

8、arm.Sowegovernmentbenchwinthenecessityment[S6]:thestateComment[S7]:同上(coverage)rightsawayFirstlycoveragerightdoesn’texistifitisaboutpersonalissues(privacy).Secondlybasedonthisclaimwecanalsosafelydrawtoaconclusionthatgove

9、rnmentshouldcomeupwithpolicieslawsasweaponstoprotecttheprivacyrightofcelebritiesnotneglectingitsdutydeprivethisrightfromthem.2.ShouldacelebritypayfhisfamebygivingupprivacyNo.Whateverhegotfromhiscareerhepaidfthemthroughhi

10、shardwkselfdecipline.Asftheopposition’sconcernthatcelebritiesmayhidedirtylittlesecretstherefehavebadinfluenceonpublicwehavealreadyprovedthatgovernmentwouldsupervisethemwithmesolidvalidpolicieslawswebelieveonlythegovernme

11、nthassuchauthitytodoso.(SummaryModel:AHRP)ThoughoutthisdebateIseemainlytwoclashes.Clash1Doesthemediacoverageofcelebrities’privacydosuchharmthatitneedtobebanned(YES)Opposition:Thesecoverageshelptosupervisecelebritiesteach

12、citizensrightfromwrongsendpositivemessagestothepublic.Us:Thesecoveragesharmthecelebritiestheirfamiliesfriendsbyaffectingtheirnmaldailylivessometimesevenarousingpersonalattacksinsults.(ZGR)Thesecoveragesharmthefans(esp.te

13、enagerswholookeduptotheirmodels)bymisleadingthemtodothesamethingtheirmodelsdid(e.g.drugabuse).Thesecoveragesharmthewholesocietyfthemediaunderitsprofitdrivennaturemayfmacompetitionofdisclosingcelebrities’privacy.Evenwseto

14、attractmeattentaintheymaytryto“create”privacywhichisnottruecausinggreaterchaosdisputes.Clash2WhoshouldbethesupervisofthecelebritiesthemediathegovernmentOpposition:MediaGovernmentMediaposessesmefactscandiscloseillegalaffa

15、irsmuchearlier.Mediahelppeopletopursuethetruth.Improvingthefunctoinofmediasavesmeresourcesthanbanningitsfunction.Us:MediaGovernmentMediasupervisioncan’tbetotallydependedon.Theadvantagesofmediasupervisionisbasedonthepremi